New South Wales > Central & North Coasts - Newcastle & Hunter Valley > Central Coast & Region > Toukley >

Simply Sicilian Pizzeria

Shop 1/268 Main Road, Toukley, 2263, NSW
Cuisine: Italian

4.5 start - 11 Reviews 4.2 5 11


Click Here to Write Review


11 Reviews for Simply Sicilian Pizzeria

4.2 5 11
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Meg
2013-05-14T16:34:48.5000000
5 1.00
1 star rating Response to richard
Believe me i never visit mcdonalds. i am an experienced home cook extraordinaire. i expect and have gotten used to quality restaurants when i do go out, e.g., the lake house at the entrance, bennelong in sydney to name a few. of course if you, richard have low standards and are used to mediocre fare you will not be dissapointed with simply sicilian. i, when i wrote my review was stating facts and my experience with the restaurant.
Food: 1 star rating Service: 1 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 1 star rating Atmosphere: 1 star rating
Meg - 5/14/2013
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Richard
2012-12-21T17:58:10.4600000
5 5.00
5.0 star rating Dear meg
Been back many times (going again tonight). great food, fabulous atmosphere and staff the envy of every restaurant on the central coast. meg, you obviously got lost on the way to mcdonalds.
Food: 5.0 star rating Service: 5.0 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 5.0 star rating Atmosphere: 5.0 star rating
Richard - 12/21/2012
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Meg
2012-10-11T21:09:11.8300000
5 1.00
1 star rating Never again!
Altogether a big disappointment. rude owner/manager. no cold table water on a really hot night. food average and service inconsistent. no byo should allow it and charge corkage. restaurant was hot and uncomfortable. mussels a huge rip off. calamari was oily and tasteless.
Food: 1 star rating Service: 1 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 1 star rating Atmosphere: 1 star rating
Meg - 10/11/2012
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Richard
2012-06-16T17:51:16.7000000
5 5.00
5.0 star rating As arnie said, "i'll be back !"
Dropped in out of the blue on friday night with wife and hungry son, lucky to get a table (obviously the locals have this place in their sights). food was superb, atmosphere made us want to stay until closing time, service was fast and staff extremely friendly. other restaurants could learn a lot from simply sicilian. can't wait to go back.
Food: 5.0 star rating Service: 5.0 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 5.0 star rating Atmosphere: 5.0 star rating
Richard - 6/16/2012
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Kathryne
2012-04-12T19:52:03.9930000
5 5.00
5.0 star rating Awesome night.
Garlic bruschetta pizza was to die for, my veal dish was mouth watering and the pannacotta was just the bomb. not to mention the wait staff were fun and friendly, we really had an awesome night there! thank you so much to the team, we will be back!
Food: 5.0 star rating Service: 5.0 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 5.0 star rating Atmosphere: 5.0 star rating
Kathryne - 4/12/2012
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Dave
2011-12-03T21:36:40.6800000
5 5.00
5.0 star rating Once again
Fine dining at it's best, as always the meals were great, service was execellent, and the owners are a gem, thank you once again job well done, and it a given we will be back
Food: 5.0 star rating Service: 5.0 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 5.0 star rating Atmosphere: 5.0 star rating
Dave - 12/3/2011
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Ed
2011-10-11T05:16:33.3030000
5 5.00
5.0 star rating Excellent
Dined there on saturday night for my daughters 28th b/day (6 adults, 2chld). i have had plenty of pizzas & italian over the years & this rates with the best. the staff were extremely friendly & helpful as well. we will return!!!!!
Food: 5.0 star rating Service: 5.0 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 5.0 star rating Atmosphere: 5.0 star rating
Ed - 10/11/2011
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Great family vibe, great service, great food
2011-10-10T15:04:50.1770000
5 4.00
4 star rating What a surprise !!
First visit here for my sister in laws birthday, the i have drivin past so many time and i will not just drive past again. we were greeted with great enthiusiasm, we had great service from all the girls who were really alot of fun ( the boss should be very happy i think, you dont get that personal service in sydney )the food was just great to, i would recomend this to evreryone,!! conratulations... we will be back and back and back. rosco
Food: 4 star rating Service: 4 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 4 star rating Atmosphere: 4 star rating
Great family vibe, great service, great food - 10/10/2011
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Carly
2011-04-14T09:27:37.2430000
5 5.00
5.0 star rating Great family atmosphere
We came here for my dad's birthday and were very impressed. it is a family-run restaurant and it shows. the staff put a lot of effort into ensuring you have a great time, including singing happy birthday! the food was amazing, the best restaurant meal i've had in a really long time- brilliant rissotto. i'll definately be back, and i'll be telling everyone i know about it. thanks very much for a wonderful dining experience!
Food: 5.0 star rating Service: 5.0 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 5.0 star rating Atmosphere: 5.0 star rating
Carly - 4/14/2011
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Bilhel
2009-02-01T05:53:19.5700000
5 5.00
5.0 star rating Well done !!!
First visit, and will not be the last by a long shot. best meal out we've experienced in a long time...a+++++++...everything from food to staff is excellent...highly recommended !!!
Food: 5.0 star rating Service: 5.0 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 5.0 star rating Atmosphere: 5.0 star rating
Bilhel - 2/1/2009
Simply Sicilian Pizzeria Anonymous
2008-10-31T17:22:46.2500000
5 5.00
5.0 star rating
Food: 5.0 star rating Service: 5.0 star rating Add owner comment
Value: 5.0 star rating Atmosphere: 5.0 star rating
Anonymous - 10/31/2008
Site Map | Contact Us
Copyright 2007-2021, Menu Mate, Inc. All rights reserved.
All prices are subject to change without prior notice.
Published menu may be slightly inaccurate. Menu Mate shall not be held responsible for any inaccuracies or typographical errors on this web site.